2025: Team Captain…D3football.com All-American First Team…Associated Press Division III First Team All-American…CFBNetwork Division III All-American First Team…D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team…AFCA Division III First Team…All-CCIW First Team…D3football.com Preseason All-American Second Team…Named to East-West Shrine Bowl Watch List…In 10 games, caught 46 passes for 488 yards and one touchdown, rushed 49 times for 308 yards and nine touchdowns, and completed 3 of 4 passes for 38 yards, accounting for 60 points on the season and showcasing his jack-of-all-trades impact as Carroll finished 4–6 overall (4–5 CCIW). 

2024: D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team…All-CCIW First Team…Appeared 10 games…Carroll’s jack-of-all trades, Breckheimer ranked ninth in the CCIW this year in receptions (36), 11th in receiving yards (476), and 12th in receiving touchdowns (3), all of which led the Pioneers…Finished third on the team in rushing with 176 yards on 32 carries (5.5 ypc), while scoring a team-high five touchdowns on the ground…Completed the only pass he threw this season for an 18-yard completion. 

2023: All-CCIW Second Team…Appeared 10 games at tight end, totaling 16 receptions, 180 receiving yards, and two touchdowns for the Pioneers…Had three catches for 36 yards and a touchdown against Elmhurst on 10/14/23…Totaled three receptions for 46 yards against Illinois Wesleyan on 9/23/23…Caught a three yard pass for a touchdown against Wisconsin Lutheran on 9/9/23… Caught four passes for 34 yards against North Park on 9/16/23. 

2022: All-CCIW Second Team…Appeared 10 games at tight end, totaling 23 receptions for 296 yards and three touchdowns…Caught five passes for 66 yards and two touchdowns against Augustana on 10/1/22…Had three catches for 51 yards and a touchdown against Wisconsin Lutheran on 9/10/22…Totaled 65 receiving yards on two catches against Illinois Wesleyan on 9/24/22.